The National Youth Orchestra Adès review captures a spectacular Proms finale where 160 teenage musicians delivered assured performances of Berlioz, Liszt, and Adès's own Dante. This concert, conducted by Thomas Adès, showcased the orchestra's remarkable growth and cohesion, ending their season with all guns blazing.
Programme Highlights and Orchestral Power
The programme featured three substantial works, keeping nearly all 160 musicians on stage throughout. The absence of theatrical gimmicks—no choreography, no body percussion—allowed the pure musicality to shine. The orchestra's sheer size was an asset, especially in Berlioz's Symphonie fantastique, where an eight-strong trombone section and four tubas created a deliciously outlandish sound.
Listeners were treated to stereo harps in the second movement and thunderous timpani in the third, with the Dies Irae motif intoned savagely on four tubas. The catastrophic ending, topped by a line of percussionists simultaneously thwacking cymbals, was a visceral thrill. However, the orchestra also navigated quieter passages with surprising agility, thanks to Adès's responsive conducting.
Thomas Adès's Conducting and Soloist Assurance
Adès's physical conducting style—crouching, lunging, and chopping—yielded textures of remarkable lucidity. In Liszt's Mephisto Waltz No 1, the ensemble took a moment to cohere but soon boasted conspiratorial woodwind and quiet elegance from strings. Throughout, Adès ceded control during solos, which were delivered with astonishing assurance by the young musicians.
The Purgatorio movement from Adès's own Dante was a highlight, emerging from gusts of air blown through brass and wind instruments to reach magnificent symphonic tintinnabulations. The recorded voice of a Jewish cantor and congregation added a profound layer, woven amid grungy basslines and keening trumpets.
Comparison Table: NYO vs. Professional Orchestras
| Aspect | National Youth Orchestra | Professional Orchestra |
|---|---|---|
| Musician Age | Teenagers (up to 19) | Adults (typically 25+) |
| Rehearsal Time | Intensive residential courses | Regular scheduled rehearsals |
| Performance Confidence | Remarkable assurance, as seen in solos | High, but often more reserved |
| Orchestral Size | 160 musicians, supersized sections | Typically 80-100 |
| Repertoire Risk | Bold choices (Berlioz, Adès) | Standard canon with occasional new works |
Key Takeaways from the Concert
- The NYO's 2023 season finale at the Proms was a display of youthful energy and professional polish.
- Berlioz's Symphonie fantastique benefited from the orchestra's oversized brass section, creating a unique sonic experience.
- Thomas Adès's conducting brought clarity and nuance to both his own work and the classics.
- Young soloists delivered with astonishing assurance, proving the NYO's training excellence.
- The inclusion of recorded cantor vocals in Adès's Dante added contemporary relevance and emotional depth.
FAQ
FAQ: What makes the National Youth Orchestra's Proms performance unique?
What makes the National Youth Orchestra's Proms performance unique?
FAQ: How did Thomas Adès conduct his own piece, Dante?
How did Thomas Adès conduct his own piece, Dante?
FAQ: What were the standout moments of the concert?
What were the standout moments of the concert?
In conclusion, this National Youth Orchestra Adès review highlights a concert that was both musically profound and emotionally stirring. The young musicians, under Adès's baton, proved that they are not just the future of classical music—they are its vibrant present. For those who missed it, this performance will be remembered as a benchmark of youth orchestral excellence.
Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of weight bench home gym, home gym equipment, treadmill home gym, adjustable dumbbells home gym, and home workouts weight loss. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.
Our testing team has hands-on reviews of sissy squat machine, home gym equipment limited space, home gym flooring, home gym cable machine, and outdoor spy. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.
How the Supersized Sections Change the Sound
Berlioz's Symphonie fantastique was written for an orchestra far smaller than the 160 musicians Adès had on stage, so the NYO's eight trombones and four tubas represent a deliberate scaling-up rather than a literal reading of the score. The Dies Irae motif, normally a modest plainchant quotation, becomes a brass event when intoned on four tubas at once. The stereo harps in the second movement and the massed cymbals at the close work on the same principle: doubling turns colour into weight.
The quieter passages are the harder test of that arithmetic. Adès's crouching, lunging and chopping gestures gave the ensemble lucidity in Liszt's Mephisto Waltz No 1, and the strings' quiet elegance there shows that 160 players can be scaled down as well as up. The recorded cantor and congregation in the Purgatorio of Dante sit alongside grungy basslines and keening trumpets, a texture that depends on the live band staying transparent enough for the tape to register.
What the Concert Does Not Establish
A single Proms finale cannot demonstrate that the NYO's model — intensive residential courses rather than regular scheduled rehearsals — reliably produces the assurance heard in the Liszt solos. The comparison with professional orchestras rests on one evening, and the article's own table concedes that professionals typically play in 80-100-strong bands with the standard canon, so the NYO's advantage in Berlioz and Adès is partly a matter of repertoire choice suiting its forces.
The Dante excerpt was one movement, Purgatorio, not the complete work, and its impact leaned on pre-recorded cantor vocals rather than solely on the teenagers on stage. The open question is whether the same cohesion survives a programme that does not place the composer on the podium; Adès ceding control during solos is a gesture of trust that another conductor may not replicate.
Where the Episode Sits in the Season
The concert closed the NYO's 2023 season, and the article frames it as the endpoint of that season's growth rather than an isolated triumph. The absence of choreography and body percussion is itself a statement: the orchestra chose to be judged on Berlioz, Liszt and Adès without theatrical framing. Placing the composer's own Dante beside Symphonie fantastique also made the case that the NYO's bold repertoire choices are a policy, not a one-off.
For the 160 players, most up to 19, the exposure is the point — a Proms finale under Adès is a credential that travels. For Adès, conducting his own Purgatorio with the same band that tackles Berlioz tests how far a composer-conductor can shape an ensemble in a single project. Whether the season's finish becomes a benchmark or an outlier depends on what the orchestra programmes next.